★
Seth MacFarlane is better heard from and not seen. After
writing and directing his first big screen feature two years ago – “Ted” – the
creator of TV’s “Family Guy” proved himself to be competent enough to take his
sense of humor onto the big screen. I really liked “Ted” and thought it was a
smart comedy, even if he flirted with crossing certain lines with his jokes.
That’s what he’s known for, so there shouldn’t be any surprises there. With his
sophomore feature “A Million Ways to Die in the West,” MacFarlane steps in
front of the camera this time and tries his hand at being a leading man. The
results are disastrous.
MacFarlane plays Albert Stark, a sheep farmer in the Arizona
frontier in 1882. He’s just been dumped by his girlfriend Louise (Amanda Seyfried),
a young woman who he says is the only reason he’s happy in this awful time and
place. His best friend is the naïve Edward (Giovanni Ribisi) who dates the town
prostitute Ruth (Sarah Silverman). Ruth sleeps with many different men in town every
day, but refuses to have sex with Edward until they’re married. Both Edward and
Ruth have Albert’s back in this difficult time, especially after Albert
discovers that Louise is now dating Foy (Neil Patrick Harris), a dashing man
with a glorious moustache.
Enter the new girl to town, Anna (Charlize Theron), who is
instantly attracted to Albert’s charming personality. What Albert doesn’t know
about Anna is she’s actually married to Clinch Leatherwood (Liam Neeson), the
most feared outlaw in the entire frontier. She keeps this little fact about her
quiet as a means to protect Albert. Anna decides that she’s going to help
Albert become a more confident person and a better gunslinger. That way he can
beat Foy in a duel and win back Louise.
The premise of “A Million Ways to Die in the West” works –
surprisingly. The storyline makes sense. The characters are likeable. There’s a
definite rooting interest in Albert and Anna. The only problem is MacFarlane
has completely polluted this entire film with the kind of trashy jokes he’s not
able to deliver on “Family Guy.” From the moment the film starts, it’s full of
juvenile toilet humor that is not at all funny.
Now, I know what you’re thinking: he did this in “Ted” too.
He did, but to an extent. The humor is very adult oriented, but it worked for
what the film was all about. Furthermore, “Ted” had a very big heart at its
core. It was a very well written and well-made film, even with the dirty jokes.
The story and the situations helped make the film funny. The dirty jokes added
to the humor.
“A Million Ways to Die in the West” completely relies on the
toilet humor to generate its laughs. Most of the jokes are overused and worn
out, having been included in just about every sex comedy since the genre began.
I’d be lying if I said this movie didn’t have its humorous moments; I did laugh
at times. But this is by no means a movie that will have you rolling in the
aisles. Unless you’re 12. Or jokes about genitals cause you endless hours of side-splitting
laughter.
MacFarlane is a decent enough actor in his own right, but
he’s probably better suited to work behind the camera, or in a voice-over
booth. He’s not a leading actor, and proves himself unworthy by essentially
playing himself here. And he doesn’t allow the rest of his supporting cast any
room to move around either. Every single person in this film has been better
elsewhere. The only person I enjoyed in this film was Harris simply because of
the absurd level in which he played his role.
I can’t say I’m surprised by anything about “A Million Ways
to Die in the West.” I was hoping MacFarlane could tap into that same type of
magic he found with “Ted” but it didn’t work at all this time out. There was no
emotional connection made at all. But should one really expect an emotional
connection from every film they see? I don’t think it’s too much to ask for.
And MacFarlane has already proved he can do that with a movie riddled with
adult jokes. Just because it’s crude doesn’t mean it can’t connect with an
audience.
The only emotions I felt out of this film with disgust and
boredom. Despite its intermittent moments of genuine humor, the film has a very
poor script that doesn’t do the story any justice. It’s a painful movie going
experience, and I was glad when it was finished.












